SITTING OUT FEATURE
The Price of Safety in ARC Raiders
Embark offered a week without hostile Raiders. For some, it was liberating. Others missed the uncertainty that made kindness mean something.
When ARC Raiders’ week-long PvE experiment ended, one player went back into the usual extraction lobbies and found himself helping a stranger fight off a Firefly and a couple of Hornets. Even after the danger had passed, the stranger kept calling out not to shoot. Later, at an extraction point, another player stood back and asked whether he could join him.
Neither encounter amounted to much. They were memorable because neither player could be entirely sure how the other would behave. In the account posted on 20 October, the writer said he had enjoyed the PvE toggle, but missed precisely this awkward, nervous little diplomacy. Others had spent the previous week enjoying the freedom from it.
That is the peculiar dispute Embark Studios now has to settle. From 13 to 20 October, players could enter raids without taking damage from one another. More than 30 million PvE rounds were played during the trial, according to the studio. On 20 October, Embark described the reaction as polarising and said it expected to report back in November. There has been no commitment to make the toggle permanent.
A return to a discarded idea
There is a certain irony in ARC Raiders entertaining a future without hostile human players. In its September announcement, Embark explained that the project began as a cooperative PvE raiding game, with looting at its centre. That version proved difficult to make work. The studio reset the design and arrived at the extraction game built around machines, other Raiders and the uneasy overlap between them.
The October test offered a glimpse of the road not taken, though not an exact reconstruction of that original design. Players could still scavenge, follow quests and tackle ARC machines, but not injure one another. They shared servers across solo, duo and trio groups. Loot values were reduced, and some higher-risk conditions — including Night Raid and the Frigate — were excluded. The experiment wasn’t a fully developed alternative campaign, and Embark said it wasn’t trying to rebalance the entire PvE game during one week.
Its interest in the idea was hardly speculative. Before the test, Embark classified 37% of its players as friendly co-op, 27% as mixed and 34% as pure PvP, and said 51% of a surveyed group had expressed interest in a dedicated PvE option. Those are the developer’s own categories and survey figures, not an independently audited referendum. Still, they help explain why this particular design argument has become difficult to put aside.
In an interview with Dot Esports before the trial, executive producer Aleksander Grøndal acknowledged the dilemma facing the studio. It had built a game around tension, while a substantial group of players wanted a way to enjoy it without the threat of being shot by another person. He also worried that a permanent PvE option could disturb both the game’s economy and its other matchmaking queues.
What a quieter Rust Belt offered
For some players, removing PvP made the machines more interesting. In an October 13 discussion, a self-described older father said the test finally gave him room to experiment with equipment and work towards his research and outpost progression. Instead of measuring every trip by the likelihood of meeting an aggressive Raider, he could plan a loadout around the ARC itself.
Another player writing near the end of the test described meeting strangers who helped one another. The account wasn’t without complaints: there were griefers, collision problems and lag spikes. But it was an argument for keeping a more cooperative space available, not a claim that the version on trial was finished.
The freedom also came with a different kind of friction. Other players complained that heavily armed groups could clear ARC encounters before anyone else arrived, leaving a less demanding and less rewarding map behind. A PvE setting doesn’t prevent competition for loot, bottlenecks or plain bad manners. It simply changes what players are able to do to each other.
Embark knew this would affect the wider economy, which is why the trial lowered loot values and left certain activities unavailable. A separate mode with its own encounter balance, rewards and progression might answer some complaints, but it would be a much larger undertaking than the October toggle. Grøndal was wary of effectively making two different games, according to the Dot Esports interview.
The people who missed the danger
It would be convenient to cast the argument as aggressive PvP enthusiasts on one side and people who want a peaceful evening on the other. The players themselves make that division difficult to maintain.
One self-described friendly solo player said they had initially welcomed PvE, only to find its lobbies quiet and strangely impersonal. Without the risk of betrayal, spontaneous alliances seemed less consequential. Returning to standard raids during the test, meanwhile, they felt that the remaining players were more aggressive. Another discussion argued that separating PvE players could change the character of PvPvE itself: its tension comes partly from not knowing whether a stranger wants a fight.
That concern is different from insisting everyone should be forced into PvP. It is about who stays in the shared queue once an alternative exists. A player who likes helping strangers, but enjoys the possibility that things may turn ugly, can find themselves choosing between guaranteed cooperation and a lobby with a greater concentration of people looking for a fight.
First thing I notice after PvE toggle is gone — player account, 20 October 2026
The extraction-point story is a good illustration. A stranger asking permission to share an exit is hardly a spectacular piece of game design. Yet the request means something because neither person is obliged to be friendly. Remove that uncertainty and the same exchange becomes a courtesy rather than a small act of trust.
One toggle, several consequences
Embark’s test has therefore raised a question larger than whether a PvE queue is popular. The studio needs to understand what happens to the player economy, the difficulty of fighting ARC, the composition of standard raids and the strange social negotiations that made its extraction game distinctive. A good experience in one queue may alter the experience in the other.
Thirty million rounds is an impressive amount of activity, but not thirty million individual players, nor proof of a lasting preference. Embark has said it is examining the data and seeking feedback, including through a survey scheduled for a sample of players from 22 October. For now, the trial is over and ordinary PvPvE matchmaking has returned.
The most useful outcome may not be an immediate yes or no to PvE. It may be a clearer understanding of which parts of ARC Raiders players are prepared to give up, and which parts they didn’t realise they valued until they were gone. When Embark reports back in November, that distinction will matter rather more than the size of the queue.
KEEP PLAYING
A good game starts with good company.
Find people who fancy the same sort of game, or see what's happening at our next event.

